Court dismisses Guy Joseph appeal

Court dismisses Guy Joseph appeal

The Court of Appeal has dismissed the appeal of Castries South East MP – Guy Joseph, in a case in which Joseph sought to have Attorney at Law, Anthony Astaphan, restrained from representing the Constituency Boundaries Commission.

The Court of Appeal in dismissing Joseph’s appeal, ordered that he pay the Commission its costs in the Court of Appeal and in the High Court.

The decision was given in open court today during a sitting in the British Virgin Islands (BVI).

On 26th February 2015, Guy Joseph had instituted legal proceedings in against the Commission, the Prime Minister and the Attorney General.

The Castries South East MP had complained that in compiling its report recommending an increase of constituencies from 17 to 21 and changes to some constituencies, the Commission had not acted independently and was improperly influenced by the ruling Saint Lucia Labour Party (SLP).

Less than a month later, on March 6, 2015, Joseph applied for an order restraining the Commission from continuing to retain Anthony Astaphan, SC to represent it in the underlying claim.

He requested an order that the Commission be independently represented by counsel who is not connected with any of the political parties or with any of the parties in the underlying claim.

The basis for Joseph’s application was, among other things, that there was a conflict since Astaphan was already on record as representing the Governor General and Prime Minister Doctor Kenny Anthony with whom he had a close relationship.

He also asserted that Astaphan had a close relationship with the Chairman of the Constituency Boundaries Commission.

The High Court judge dismissed Joseph’s application for a number of reasons including that evidence of Astaphan’s long standing relationship with the Prime Minister, the Chairman of the Commission, and newspaper reports, was not sufficient to prove that he was a political activist.

The Court of Appeal in its judgement found that the High Court judge did apply the correct test in making a determination on whether Astaphan, was suitable to represent the Commission.

It also said the judge applied the correct standard of proof in considering the evidence in the case.

According to the Court of Appeal judgement, the jurisdiction of the court to restrain a legal practitioner from representing a litigant is an exceptional one and ought to be exercised with caution.

It asserted that” compelling evidence” would be required for the court to make a determination that a legal practitioner should be restrained from continuing to represent his client.

Related Articles


  1. Anonymous
    April 6, 2016 at 1:36 pm Reply

    Take that Guy….. !!!!!! Now pay the court it money for wasting time and man power !!!!

    You are a clown and I hope you understand that you are just that !!!!!

  2. Ti Mike
    April 6, 2016 at 1:47 pm Reply

    His appointment was completely political. He has milked this country dry in his legal representation. I would like to see how much the SLP politburo has paid him over the years for such dubious representation. St.Lucia has been raped by this evil cabal.

    1. The Crow
      December 21, 2016 at 8:13 am Reply

      Wait a minute! Are you an ignoramus? What about Amorsingh? How many times has the UWP employ him? Has he not milked the coffers only to lose his pants . . . to who else? Astaphan! Like him or not, Astaphan is brilliant at what he does and I would rather have him than Amorsingh.

  3. David
    April 6, 2016 at 1:51 pm Reply

    Let this illiterate mini-bus driver languish in his “struggling” state of brainless abyss.

  4. Anonymous
    April 6, 2016 at 2:23 pm Reply

    Ti Mike will you please explain or from a word to describe $17 million that did not make it way to the people of St.Lucia…..

    The Taiwan Funds!!!!!

    Thank you sir….

    1. Blindspot
      April 6, 2016 at 3:29 pm Reply

      If that is the case, why won’t the Prime Minister bring them to Court? Is it because Guy also has dirt on them. SMH

  5. lucian
    April 6, 2016 at 2:28 pm Reply

    I hope he go n debate dat also in d house.Guy d mapwe Philip J Pierre sent for Kenny through Dominc Fedee was well said in court today.ha ha ha.Now its ur turn to spread it through. Its ur choice to shoose now. Pipe start smoking n I already high.

  6. Anonymous
    April 6, 2016 at 6:00 pm Reply

    When you go to court with slp it’s a stag deck you can’t win. No matter how you bluff. These guys have their own tricks from Juge. Lawyers. Magestrats police name it. You can’t win.
    This is Saint Lucia where crukedness is the main economic development and growth.

  7. Heidi
    April 6, 2016 at 6:33 pm Reply

    Mr. Chastenet, when you take office, can you please tell us how much Kenny Anthony has paid Astaphane over the years. People are dying and the police have no resources. They cannot open the forensics lab, yet they waste money on this outsider that takes St.Lucians for fools. This stinks and for sure I won’t trust CCJ.

    1. The Crow
      December 21, 2016 at 1:28 pm Reply

      If it had gone the other way, you would be singing a different song . . . I love de CCJ.

  8. cocoflow
    April 6, 2016 at 7:00 pm Reply

    haaa Guy u didn’t realize that wasn’t ur ROLE so sense when that was ur role without d whole UWP party to stand behind u

  9. Gerber
    December 20, 2016 at 11:57 am Reply

    Wait for the next bombshell when Thomas Eugene done with him. All taxes collected are for legal fees

Leave a Reply