Both the Police Marine Unit and the Saint Lucia Air and Sea Ports Authority have now pointed to speed as a factor in the deadly Anse Cochon boat collision.
Since public hearings of the inquiry began in October, commissioners have repeatedly returned to one question: How fast were Ocean Angel and Cazorla Jr travelling when they collided?
The extent of the damage to both vessels, along with the injuries sustained by passengers, has kept that issue firmly in focus, even as passengers and operators have been careful in how they have described their speed in the moments leading up to impact.
In an earlier sitting, Romean Williams, who was aboard Cazorla Jr, told the Commission that the vessel was travelling at a “really good speed” at one point during the trip.
Owner Irenus Pascal described it as a “little more than moderate” and recalled asking captain Tyson Hippolyte to “take it easy”. According to Pascal, Hippolyte reduced his speed after that request.
There were similar questions about Ocean Angel.
Tyrone Paul, who was one of the four people who lost their lives in the collision, had been operating the vessel at the start of the journey before owner Dylan Nicholas later took over.
During his line of questioning, Elias Nicholas, a fisherman from Soufrière who was aboard Ocean Angel, was asked to compare how the two men handled the boat.
“Tyrone was taking it more easy on the boat; Dylan was going more faster,” he said.
Dylan Nicholas, however, denied travelling at excessive speed. During his testimony, he described his speed as “more than moderate” and said he adjusted it depending on the waves and conditions.
The clearest assessments on speed so far have come from officials who examined the aftermath of the collision.
At the November 9 sitting, Acting Sergeant Mario Chicot of the Police Marine Unit told the Commission that, in his estimation, both vessels would have had to be travelling at “considerable speed” given the extent of the damage.
That view was later supported by SLASPA ship surveyor Peter Joseph, who inspected both boats after the collision.
Taking the stand on November 18, Joseph described what he saw as a “high impact collision”.
“Speed was involved there,” he told the Commission.
When pressed further, Joseph was more direct.
“There was speeding,” he said, surmising that both vessels were travelling at a high speed.



