Joy St Omer’s tragic death has sparked national outrage, with many people openly asking if the systems meant to protect vulnerable people failed her in her last weeks.
Youth activist Alens Plante and Sister Rufina Donat, principal of St Joseph’s Convent, have joined in the call for a full review of the justice system, law enforcement and social support services after St Omer’s death.
Their concerns grew after it was revealed that St Omer had reported her estranged husband to authorities several times. He was arrested for allegedly breaking a protective order and assaulting her, but was later released on bail. Less than a month later, St Omer was killed.
The case has renewed public debate about how domestic violence and gender-based violence are handled in Saint Lucia.
Rufina, who once taught St Omer, hopes this tragedy will lead to real change.
“I just hope that the system itself can be reviewed. The judiciary system, the laws, the police, every system needs to be reviewed so that what has happened to Joy would not just go in vain,” she said.
She said protecting women and children should be a national priority and stressed the importance of teaching respect and healthy relationships from a young age.
“We have to teach our young men how to respect women, and we have to teach our women what to accept and what not to accept. Too often it becomes casual, and we are saying now it cannot be casual,” Rufina said.
She said that accountability is not just for law enforcement and the courts. Families, schools, churches, and communities all have a part to play in stopping violence.
“The judiciary system has to look at itself. The Attorney General’s Office has to look at itself. The police, everybody, because every case is different, every case is individual,” she said.
At first, Sister Rufina said she was disturbed by what happened to St Omer. After thinking more about it, she said she felt angry about what she saw as failures in the system.
“When reviewing the whole system now, there is a little anger because you felt that the system had failed there,” she said.
She also pointed out that the case has affected the mental well-being of other young women.
“It created fear in other young people, other young women who are dating. The question many young women were asking was, ‘How do I trust my partner?’”
Youth activist Alens Plante agreed, saying the situation showed serious problems in how women are protected.
“I feel personally we continue to fail our women tremendously,” Plante said. “I think that it was a situation that was perhaps grossly negligent, and our women continue to be subjected to situations that they should not have been.”
Plante said that if action had been taken sooner, things might have turned out differently.
“I think this is a situation that should have been handled a long time ago, and Joy would have still been with her family and friends today,” he stated.
The activist spoke strongly about the important role women have in society and wondered why stronger protections are not in place.
“Women are the foundation of our society. I can’t imagine life without my mother. I have sisters that I love tremendously, and I can’t imagine life without them. They nurture, they care, they make the next prime ministers, they make farmers, they make everything that forms part and parcel of what our society is.”
Plante said authorities need to take more responsibility when handling reports of abuse and violence against women.
“Our authorities should be on the ball as it relates to situations like that,” he said. “We need to have a different approach, a complete turnover, as to how we deal with situations that relate to gender-based violence, particularly against women.”
Public anger grew after a letter surfaced that St Omer reportedly sent to the Royal Saint Lucia Police Force, asking to drop charges against her husband. In the letter, she said she had lost faith in the justice system and doubted that continuing would lead to a good result.
People are still calling for accountability. Many in Saint Lucia want a full review of the systems meant to protect victims of domestic violence, hoping that what happened to St Omer will lead to changes that stop this from happening again.
I still want a full explanation from the High Court why they overturn the decision and granted this man bail. He had a clear pattern of violence toward her and refusal to honor the protection agreement. The High Court knew this and still granted bail. That is unacceptable! This needs to be looked into and someone needs to be held accountable for overturning the lower court’s decision. The lower court had protection in place by refusing to grant bail. So why did the High Court overturn that decision? It makes no sense and it makes me very angry. The High Court judge that made this decision is partially responsible for her death. He needs to be held accountable.
In St. Lucia treatment is provided not based on the law but who you know and the $$$$ for which some of you will sell your soul. You see most of you are related or know each other …”the my girl my boy syndrome bayteeze” …you all need to learn to conduct business in a professional manner with everyone both government and NGOs.
I will never ever uphold or even cover for any friend or family member when they are doing wrong and I have made it abundantly clear that I will turn them in period full stop ..you see I have a God fearing conscience .. it not so in St. Lucia. Some parents uphold, cover and partake of funds and ill gotten gains from their children. Please understand karma knows everyone’s address for real. Some of you even compare your 238 square miles to the US …make that make sense.
When you violate an order of protection in the US you will be apprehended. You are also commanded by law to remain a certain number of feet from the individual. Failure to pay child support can also lead to drivers license being revoked and in some instances your passport and ability to travel will be affected in the US. In St. Lucia you will probably get a high five and a thumbs up. Paar Dee poor jab ..you all are too much for real Some of you will not last a day anywhere else outside of St. Lucia.